| Rank | Artist | Recording | Label | User Supplied Version |
| 1 | SHINS | Port Of Morrow | Columbia | |
| 2 | LOST IN THE TREES | A Church That Fits Our Needs | Anti | |
| 3 | M. WARD | A Wasteland Companion | Merge | |
| 4 | BEAR IN HEAVEN | I Love You, It’s Cool | Hometapes-Dead Oceans | |
| 5 | OBERHOFER | Time Capsules II | Glassnote | |
| 6 | DINOSAUR FEATHERS | Whistle Tips | Ernest Jenning | |
| 7 | LA SERA | Sees The Light | Hardly Art | |
| 8 | SCREAMING FEMALES | Ugly | Don Giovanni | |
| 9 | SHARON VAN ETTEN | Tramp | Jagjaguwar | |
| 10 | ANDREW BIRD | Break It Yourself | Mom And Pop | |
| 11 | BOWERBIRDS | The Clearing | Dead Oceans | |
| 12 | XIU XIU | Always | Polyvinyl | |
| 13 | AU | Both Lights | Hometapes | |
| 14 | HORSE FEATHERS | Cynic’s New Year | Kill Rock Stars | |
| 15 | SHEARWATER | Animal Joy | Sub Pop | |
| 16 | MAPS AND ATLASES | Beware And Be Grateful | Barsuk | |
| 17 | SARAH JAFFE | The Body Wins | Kirtland | |
| 18 | LAMBCHOP | Mr. M | Merge | |
| 19 | TORO Y MOI | June 2009 | Carpark | |
| 20 | MEMORYHOUSE | The Slideshow Effect | Sub Pop | |
| 21 | DAMIEN JURADO | Maraqopa | Secretly Canadian | |
| 22 | DENISON WITMER | The Ones Who Wait | Asthmatic Kitty | |
| 23 | SLEIGH BELLS | Reign Of Terror | Mom And Pop | |
| 24 | ALABAMA SHAKES | Boys And Girls | ATO | |
| 25 | THEESATISFACTION | AwE NaturalE | Sub Pop | |
| 26 | LUMINEERS | The Lumineers | Self-Released | |
| 27 | YANN TIERSEN | Skyline | Anti | |
| 28 | CLOUD NOTHINGS | Attack On Memory | Carpark | |
| 29 | MIIKE SNOW | Happy To You | Universal Republic | |
| 30 | FANFARLO | Rooms Filled With Light | Canvasback |
Top 30: 4/23/12
