| Rank | Artist | Recording | Label | User Supplied Version |
| 1 | IRON AND WINE | Kiss Each Other Clean | Warner Bros. | |
| 2 | SMITH WESTERNS | Dye It Blond | Fat Possum | |
| 3 | TENNIS | Cape Dory | Fat Possum | |
| 4 | NO JOY | Ghost Blonde | Mexican Summer | |
| 5 | DESTROYER | Kaputt | Merge | |
| 6 | ELVIS COSTELLO | National Ransom | Hear | |
| 7 | DEERHOOF | Deerhoof Vs. Evil | Polyvinyl | |
| 8 | MATT AND KIM | Sidewalks | Fader | |
| 9 | BLANK DOGS | Land And Fixed | Captured Tracks | |
| 10 | BELLE AND SEBASTIAN | Write About Love | Matador | |
| 11 | DELICATE STEVE | Wondervisions | Luaka Bop | |
| 12 | GOSPEL CLAWS | C-L-A-W-S | Common Wal | |
| 13 | AKRON/FAMILY | S/T II: The Cosmic Birth And Journey Of Shinju TNT | Dead Oceans | |
| 14 | FRESH AND ONLYS | Play It Strange | In The Red | |
| 15 | WOLF AND CUB | Science And Sorcery | Last Gang | |
| 16 | ESKMO | Eskmo | Ninja Tune | |
| 17 | SUUNS | Zeroes QC | Secretly Canadian | |
| 18 | DOLOREAN | The Unfazed | Partisan | |
| 19 | INTERPOL | Interpol (2010) | Matador | |
| 20 | DUCKTAILS | Ducktails III: Arcade Dynamics | Woodsist | |
| 21 | MOGWAI | Hardcore Will Never Die, But You Will | SUB POP | |
| 22 | JOHN VANDERSLICE | White Wilderness | Dead Oceans | |
| 23 | LAND OF TALK | Cloak And Cipher | Saddle Creek | |
| 24 | RADIO DEPT. | Passive Aggressive: Singles 2002-2010 | Labrador | |
| 25 | GOLD PANDA | Lucky Shiner | Ghostly International | |
| 26 | COLD WAR KIDS | Mine Is Yours | Downtown | |
| 27 | FITZ AND THE TANTRUMS | Santa Stole My Lady | Dangerbird | |
| 28 | WHITE LIES | Ritual | Interscope | |
| 29 | SMALL SINS | Pot Calls Kettle Back | Arts And Crafts | |
| 30 | HUNDRED IN THE HANDS | Hundred In The Hands | Warp |